Fiduciary · Nevada Registered Investment Advisor · CRD #283916Simplifying Wealth.®
How Money Works · Markets & the Big Picture · Stocks & the Markets · Understanding Investing

Who’s in Charge of the Market?

This past week, the GDP report showed that the economy contracted for the second consecutive quarter, putting us on the cusp of an official recession. On that news, the stock market rallied. Sometimes the market moves in the opposite…

Scott Gardner, IAR · CRD #6720246
Published September 15, 2022 · 3 min read
Who’s in Charge of the Market?

This past week, the GDP report showed that the economy contracted for the second consecutive quarter, putting us on the cusp of an official recession. On that news, the stock market rallied. Sometimes the market moves in the opposite direction than people think it should. Today, I will share what I’ve learned about the market and explain why it sometimes has contrarian shifts like last week.

Two Key Influencers

I have found that two main groups of people are the most significant influencers of the future value of stocks and the market—analysts and economists. The analyst’s job is to analyze a company’s financials and project what they believe is a fair price for a stock. The economist’s job is to analyze the economy and forecast where they believe the country is heading.

The Efficient Market Hypothesis

There is a financial concept called the efficient market hypothesis, which says that any news (good or bad) is priced into the market as soon as it is known. When analysts or economists paint a rosy picture of the future, the market reacts positively to that news as if the outcome is almost certain.

Here’s how this works. Suppose economists projected that we will experience the most robust economy we’ve ever seen—the market will increase on that expectation. Then, suppose that the future economy turns out to be strong but not as rosy as was expected—the market will decline because it had already priced in a rosier future and was disappointed.

The same thing happens to individual company stocks. Analysts project how a company should perform in the foreseeable future. In most cases, the stock price adjusts when analysts release their projections. Then, if a company’s earnings disappoint expectations, the stock price will decline even if the company has record profits.

Prices Are Set by Millions of Decisions

No single person or institution controls the market. Prices are set by millions of buyers and sellers, each acting on their own information and expectations. Policymakers and large investors can influence it, but no one can command it. That is why humility—and a diversified, long-term plan—serves investors better than trying to predict what any one player will do next.

Even the most influential voices—central bankers, corporate leaders, and major investors—are often surprised by how markets react. If the experts can’t reliably predict it, individual investors are better served by focusing on a plan they can control.

What the Market Has Priced In

Over the past six months, I have told you that the stock market has priced in a near-term, moderate recession. One of the reasons the stock market rallied after another negative GDP reading last week is that economists had expected the decline to be more significant than it was, and a bleaker economic outlook had already been priced into the market.

The market doesn’t always move in the way people expect, but now you know one of the reasons for that phenomenon. Happy investing! Ü

This article is for educational purposes only and is not individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. Laws and individual circumstances vary, so consult a qualified professional before acting on any strategy discussed. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results. See the full disclosures.