Fiduciary · Nevada Registered Investment Advisor · CRD #283916Simplifying Wealth.®
Markets & the Big Picture · Understanding Investing · Stocks & the Markets

The Rise of Robinhood

In February 2020, we started hearing about a Coronavirus developing in China. The Chinese government responded by locking down the entire city of Wuhan and surrounding areas. At first glance, it appeared that their…

Scott Gardner, IAR · CRD #6720246
Published September 1, 2020 · 10 min read
The Rise of Robinhood

In February 2020, we started hearing about a Coronavirus developing in China. The Chinese government responded by locking down the entire city of Wuhan and surrounding areas. At first glance, it appeared that their response way overblown and irrational. Six months later, we are still in the midst of our own government-mandated lock down with no perceivable end in sight. This shut down has had an immediate and massive impact on the United States economy—one that will shutter many companies indefinitely. Despite the economic turmoil, the stock market is soaring at all-time highs. I am going to share my thoughts on why this might be and how to prepare for the future of investing.

This Is Not 2008

It is human nature to reflect on past events to try to make sense of current events that don’t fit our narrative or expected outcome. There are many people who are looking at the Great Recession to determine a pattern that they can use to navigate the current economic turmoil. On its surface, this make sense since it was the last modern recession. However, economies change, the pieces move, and the variables are altered. Don’t believe me? In 2008, the iPhone 3G had just come out. Compared to the iPhone 11, it had 16x less storage, 3x less image quality, and it didn’t even have Bluetooth! Here are some other major differences between 2008 and today: The 2008 recession was triggered by an overheated housing market with unqualified buyers taking out mortgages and banks leveraging loans to astronomical levels. The current recession is triggered by a pandemic. Household debt in 2008 was 134% of GDP and it is currently at a historically low 96% of

GDP. This means that fewer people are over-leveraged in 2020. The household savings rate was 3.6% in 2008 and it is now 8%. The difference in these numbers mean that Americans can continue spending at a slightly reduced level today where they couldn’t spend at all in 2008. In other words, consumers are in good shape. In 2008, the unemployment rate hit 10% compared to the 14.7% unemployment record hit in April 2020. While the unemployment highs are expected to be more temporary than the 2008, they are still more significant. In 2008, corporations had $5.8 trillion in rated debt with only $3.8 trillion being investment grade. Today, corporations have $9.3 trillion in rated debt with $6.7 trillion being considered investment grade. In layman’s terms, a higher percentage of corporate debt is secured by stable companies with strong expectations of repayment. In 2008, banks had weak balance sheets and had flawed business practices that forced the government to bail them out. Today, banks are required to have stronger balance sheets and are required to participate in regular stress tests. In 2008, the government was slow to provide a stimulus package that would be effective. In 2020, the government moved in a quick, concerted effort to stimulate the economy. And finally, the real estate market in 2008 was a bubble ready to pop and current housing prices are generally sustainable.

Why Are Stocks Jumping?

Generally speaking, the stock market attempts to price in the value of all known and projected information. For example, if the government is actively talking about breaking up a company perceived as a monopoly, the stock may take a hit because the company’s competitive advantage is being threatened which could result in higher customer acquisition costs. The market then attempts to subtract the cost of splitting the company and the potential negative impacts the division would have on the remaining segment’s ability to do business from the stocks price. At the beginning of the year, I believe the stock market was accurately pricing in the potential of a long-term government shut down and significant business interruptions. However, even though some price adjustments in the market were warranted, I believe that the market was overselling on these fears. Since the March 2020 lows, the stock market has rallied 55% to surpass its all time highs despite the underlying economic woes. On top of that, one of Warren Buffett’s measurements of stock market valuation (total stock market to GDP ratio) indicates that the market is significantly overvalued right now. So, if the market prices in all known/projected information and we are most likely in a recession with really high unemployment and companies that are going bankrupt almost daily, how is it possible that the stock market is doing so well? While it is impossible to identify all factors that are contributing to the stock market’s rise, I am going to explore some possibilities and potential underlying factors that are likely contributors. Robust Savings. As previously identified, the American household debt and savings rates were at all-time highs going into 2020. Unlike 2008 where people were so strapped for cash that any financial hiccup would cause them to default on their obligations, Americans learned from their mistakes and have been squirreling away money for years to prepare for the this hiccup. Government Stimulus. When states started shutting down, the government acted swiftly to pass the roughly $2.2 trillion CARES Act in order to stimulate and prop up the economy. Of those funds, $610 billion was earmarked towards households, $525 billion for large businesses, $600 billion for small businesses, and $545 billion for municipalities/infrastructure. Additionally, with the extension of unemployment benefits, many low-paid workers received a significant pay increase from being on unemployment. Unemployment Benefits. Since Americans already had substantial savings at the beginning of the year and unemployment benefits have been so frothy, I believe that unemployment (and the possibility of being unemployed) has not been a significant concern for many people. Based on that assumption, I believe a large chunk of the $610 billion earmarked for households simply became excess cash for them to invest. But that’s not all, much of the money earmarked towards businesses also likely found its way into stock investments. Based on my analysis, it would not surprise me if over $1 trillion of the roughly $2.2 trillion stimulus made its way into the stock market and other investments. First-Time Investors. This article is entitled The Rise of Robinhood—I added a picture of an archer as a play on words. In realty, Robinhood is the popular trading app that has become the go-to for many Millennials and first-time investors and not the Robin Hood that stole from the rich to give to the poor. First-time investors have a tendency to speculate in the stock market and generally invest in popular stocks. When you pay firsttime investors a lot of money while they are on unemployment, give them lots of time, and then drop $610 billion on them, you have a recipe for runaway speculation!

Testing My Theories

Robinhood regularly publishes the top stocks that their users are buying. A recent article shows that the top ten acquisitions for speculative purchases are Tesla (TSLA), Amazon (AMZN), Apple (AAPL), Moderna (MRNA), Pfizer (PFE), Eastman Kodak (KODK), Nio (NIO), Microsoft (MSFT), Netflix (NFLX), and Spartan Energy (SPAQ). To support my theory, I am going to take a closer look at the activity on some of these stocks to see if they could have been affected by the cash from the CARES act. Before I get started, I need to tell you about the Price-to-Earnings (PE) Ratio which represents the value of a stock relative to its earnings—it is an indicator whether an individual stock is over/under valued. Generally speaking, a PE Ratio under 40x earnings is a fair valuation. Anything over 40x can indicate a temporary hiccup in earnings or a significant overvaluation and complete disregard for risk and logic. Tesla (TSLA) Tesla stock has increased 496% since its March 2020 lows. The average number of shares traded went from 192 million shares per month in 2019 to 352 million shares per month in 2020—an 83% increase. Tesla has a PE Ratio of 1,115x earnings. To put that into perspective, Toyota has a PE Ratio of 8x earnings and Honda has a PE Ratio of 4x earnings. Tesla also boasts a $400 billion valuation compared to Toyota’s $188 billion valuation despite the fact that Toyota sells 10x more vehicles than Tesla. Amazon (AMZN) Amazon stock has increased 105% since its March 2020 lows. The average number of shares traded went from 81 million shares per month in 2019 to 104 million shares per month in 2020—a 28% increase. Amazon has a PE Ratio of 132x earnings. To put that into perspective, Wal-Mart has a PE Ratio of 21x earnings and Target has a PE Ratio of 22x earnings. Apple (AAPL) Apple stock has increased 126% since its March 2020 lows. The average number of shares traded went from 588 million shares per month in 2019 to 872 million shares per month in 2020—a 48% increase. It is also important to note that March 2020 traded 1.57 billion shares—a 167% increase over its 2019 average. Apple has a PE Ratio of 38x earnings. Netflix (NFLX) Netflix stock has increased 83% since its March 2020 lows. The average number of shares traded went from 165 million shares per month in 2019 to 159 million shares per month in 2020—a surprising 4% decrease. Netflix has a PE Ratio of 92x earnings. I could go on and on, but I think you get the point. I reviewed many popular stocks and found that most of the stocks that I looked at saw a significant uptick in the number of shares being traded in 2020 and many of them have very high valuations. Based on this, I believe that the timing of the increases in volume and the passage of the CARES act are closely correlated.

Conclusion

In 2013, I fell prey to a classic beginning investor blunder—I bought heavily into a hyped stock on its upside potential. That stock was 3D Systems (DDD). It was the first publicly traded 3D printing manufacturer, it “was far ahead of the competition”, and “everything was going to be 3D printed in the future.” I felt like it was a no-brainer and invested heavily. I watched that stock go from $5 per share to over $92 per share in less than a year. Then, I watched the stock go from $92 per share down to $5 per share where it has remained ever since. I share this story with you because I see similar things occurring in the market right now—lots of leveraged speculation on the future of companies that is resulting in driving stock prices to unreasonable levels. In such a market, here is what I recommend you do: 1. Don’t Fall Prey to Hype. During hot markets, you are going to hear how a certain company stock is “the wave of the future”, “it will never be this cheap again”, and that “there is no way you can go wrong.” During such markets, you will get an overwhelming fear of missing out (FOMO). To insulate yourself from the many opinions that you are going to hear, I recommend two things: (1) follow Warren Buffett’s philosophy to be “fearful when others are greedy, and greedy when others are fearful.” and (2) create a personal investment guide that includes your risk tolerances, your investment goals, your investment limits, your investment purposes, and key investment philosophies that you will use to guide you. 2. Don’t Put All Your Eggs in One Basket. It is true that if you take 100% of your investable assets and put it into a single investment, that you could potentially have astronomical gains that will make you wealthy. It is also true that you can lose everything. Investing is about strategic allocations whereas gambling is rolling the dice on a single potential outcome. Don’t confuse these two. If you want to gamble in the stock market—call it what it is. If you want to invest in the stock market, spread your investments over many excellent and reputable companies. 3. Focus on the Principal and Not the Interest. A true investment should return your money to you and provide you with gains. Only invest money you can afford to have tied up or lose. Then let the investment prove itself over time. I try to weed out the bad and speculative investments by looking at the company’s financial statements to see which ones are well run. Another way you can eliminate companies that may not return your investment is by looking at the total price of its stock (market cap) and ask yourself if you’d buy the company for that much if you had the capital. If the answer is no, then you may not want to buy the stock. Investing can be fun and very rewarding when done well and it can be a nightmare when done poorly. If you’re new to the game of investing and personal finance, I’d recommend you read “I Will Teach You To Be Rich” by Ramit Sethi. That will give you a good flavor of what you’re getting into. Happy investing! Ü Want to know how I got into stocks and investments? Watch this video.

This article is for educational purposes only and is not individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. Laws and individual circumstances vary, so consult a qualified professional before acting on any strategy discussed. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results. See the full disclosures.