Free Trading Is Not Free
Major brokers cut stock commissions to zero this month. Here is what to watch for.
Published October 14, 2019 · 3 min read
On October 1, Charles Schwab announced it would eliminate commissions on online trades of U.S. stocks and ETFs. Within days, TD Ameritrade, E*TRADE, and others followed. For individual investors, the cost of buying a share of stock has effectively dropped to zero.
The Good News
Lower costs are good for investors. Commissions used to eat into returns, especially for people investing small amounts. Now someone investing $100 a month is not losing a meaningful percentage of it to trading fees.
But Nothing Is Truly Free
Brokers still need to make money. They may do so through:
- Interest on Cash. Earning a spread on uninvested cash sitting in your account.
- Payment for Order Flow. Being paid by market makers that execute your trades.
- Other Products. Fund fees, margin lending, and advisory services.
None of this is necessarily bad, but you should understand how your broker is paid.
The Bigger Risk Is Behavior
When trading costs nothing, it becomes easy to trade too much. Frequent buying and selling can lead to higher taxes in taxable accounts and decisions based on emotion rather than a plan. Studies of individual investor behavior have generally found that people who trade more often tend to earn less.
How Brokers Still Make Money
When a service is free, it is worth asking how the company gets paid. Brokers that offer commission-free trades still need revenue, and they earn it in several ways. Some are paid by market makers to route customer orders to them, a practice known as payment for order flow. Others earn interest on the cash customers leave uninvested in their accounts, often paying customers only a small portion of what they earn. Some make money from margin lending, premium subscriptions, or by offering their own investment products.
None of these practices are necessarily bad, but they mean the true cost of a trade may be hidden in the price you receive or the interest you don’t earn. Understanding how your broker is paid helps you evaluate whether “free” really is the best deal.
Watch the Costs You Can’t See
Commissions are only one cost of investing. Fund expense ratios, bid-ask spreads, taxes on short-term gains, and the cost of frequent trading all add up. Over decades, small differences in cost can have a large effect on your results because those fees compound just like returns do. A good rule of thumb is to keep costs low, trade only when you have a clear reason, and let your long-term plan—not the ease of clicking a button—guide your decisions.
It is also worth remembering that easy trading can encourage too much trading. When buying and selling takes a single tap, it is tempting to react to every headline or hot tip. Research has generally found that investors who trade frequently tend to earn less than those who buy and hold, largely because of poorly timed decisions. The best investment habit is often the least exciting one: build a diversified portfolio and leave it alone.
The Takeaway
Zero commissions remove one cost of investing. They do not remove the need for discipline, diversification, and a long-term plan.